Medicare hold harmless rule for Part B and Social Security
When a Medicare Part B premium goes up, the question in a lot of Greensboro households is whether the Social Security deposit will go down. Federal law has a rule, which the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services calls the hold-harmless provision, that can reduce that year's Part B premium so the premium increase does not reduce the net Social Security payment. [1] The protection is real, but it does not freeze the premium for every person with Medicare. Several common situations sit outside it. [1][6]
What the rule does to the check
The rule is in section 1839(f) of the Social Security Act. CMS explains it this way. If you are entitled to an Old-Age and Survivors Insurance benefit or a Disability Insurance benefit, and the Part B premium is deducted from those payments, the premium increase is reduced if that is what it takes to avoid a decrease in your net monthly payment. [1] That decrease happens when the dollar increase in your Social Security benefit from the cost-of-living adjustment is smaller than the dollar increase in the premium. [1]
Social Security pays a month behind. A benefit for November is not received until December, and December's Part B premium is the one deducted from that check. [1] When the protection applies, the reduced premium lasts for January and the rest of that calendar year. It is the greater of two amounts: the new January premium, reduced so the net benefit does not fall, or the premium paid for December. [1] Social Security's Program Operations Manual, in a section dated February 2, 2023 and still in effect, tells staff to reduce the premium so the check received in January, after the premium, equals the check received in December. [3]
That is a floor under the net payment, not a promise that the deposit will rise by the full cost-of-living adjustment. If the cost-of-living increase covers the full premium increase, you pay the new standard premium, and the net payment can still rise by less than the headline percentage. [1][3] The rule is about that monthly premium, not the Part B deductible you pay when you use care. In 2026 that deductible is $283, paid once in the year. [2]
The 2026 standard premium
CMS published the 2026 standard monthly Part B premium at $202.90. That is 9.7 percent, or $17.90, higher than the 2025 standard premium of $185.00. [1] A CMS fact sheet from November 14, 2025 states the same increase, $17.90, from $185.00 to $202.90. [4] Medicare's 2026 costs sheet says most people pay that standard amount, and that Social Security will tell you the exact amount you will pay. [2]
We are not stating a 2027 Part B premium here. The comparison that matters is the one CMS describes: your own cost-of-living increase in dollars, set next to your own premium increase in dollars. [1] Under that formula, the protected premium is the greater of last December's premium and the new premium reduced only as far as needed to keep the net payment from falling. [1] The rule is federal, so it works the same way in Greensboro and the rest of the Piedmont as it does anywhere else. What changes is the size of the benefit, whether the premium is deducted, and whether an exception applies.
Who can qualify
The manual says this variable premium applies only if all of the following are true. You are entitled to Social Security benefits for November and December. The Part B premiums for December and January are deducted from those benefits. You receive a cash benefit for November and December. And, solely because the Part B increase is high compared with the benefit, the January payment would be lower than the December payment. [3]
The manual also says the law protects Title II benefits and Railroad Retirement Board benefits from decreasing because of year-to-year Part B increases. Title II beneficiaries and Railroad Retirement annuitants are considered for this protection unless they pay an income-related Part B premium. [3] Medicare says most people have the Part B premium deducted automatically from Social Security or a Railroad Retirement Board payment. [5] MedPAC says roughly 70 percent of Part B enrollees have premiums deducted from Social Security and could be subject to the provision. [6] "Could be" matters. Being in that group means the rule can look at your check. It does not mean your premium will be reduced.
Who is not protected
Medicare's 2026 costs sheet says you pay the standard premium amount if you sign up for Part B for the first time in 2026, you do not get Social Security benefits, you are directly billed for your Part B premiums, or you have Medicare and Medicaid and Medicaid pays your premiums. If Medicaid pays the premium, the sheet says your state will pay the standard amount of $202.90 in 2026. [2] The same sheet says most people pay the standard amount. [2] A reduced premium is a separate step, used only when the dollar test in the CMS notice is met. [1]
MedPAC draws the same line. The provision does not apply to enrollees who do not receive a Social Security benefit, who pay an income-related monthly adjustment amount, who are dually eligible and have the state Medicaid program pay the Part B premium, or who are new to Part B that year. People who are not held harmless pay the standard premium, plus an income-related amount and a late-enrollment penalty if those apply. [6]
If you sign up for Part B for the first time in 2026, you pay the standard premium. [2] People new to Part B that year are outside the provision. [6] If you do not get Social Security or Railroad Retirement Board benefits, Medicare sends a premium bill. A bill for Part B only, including a Part B income-related amount if you owe one, comes every three months. [5] Read the monthly amount on that bill, not only the quarterly total.
If a state Medicaid program pays the premium, the manual says this protection stops when that state payment begins, and the state pays the regular, non-variable premium. [3] Medicare's costs sheet says the state will pay the standard premium of $202.90 in 2026. [2]
The income-related surcharge is outside the rule
CMS says the hold-harmless provision does not apply to people who must pay an income-related monthly adjustment amount. [1] The manual says anyone paying that income-related Part B premium does not get the variable premium. [3]
Medicare's 2026 costs sheet says that if modified adjusted gross income on the IRS return from two years ago is above a set amount, you pay the standard Part B premium plus that income-related amount. The sheet's table for 2026 is headed as income in 2024. At $109,000 or less on an individual return, or $218,000 or less on a joint return, the amount shown is the standard $202.90. Above those amounts, the premium is higher. [2] CMS says these income-related amounts affect roughly 8 percent of people with Medicare Part B. [4]
We will not rebuild the brackets here. The steps and the two-year lookback are in our article on the 2026 income-related Part B premium for Greensboro retirees. If you owe that surcharge, hold harmless does not trim the Part B premium. [1][6] Do not assume this Part B rule caps a separate Part D plan premium. [1]
A late enrollment penalty is added on top
Hold harmless does not erase a Part B late enrollment penalty. CMS says people who enrolled late, or who re-enrolled after coverage ended, pay an increased premium figured on the new premium rate before any hold-harmless reduction. [1] The manual says the 10 percent per year surcharge is calculated on the full premium, before any variable-premium reduction, and that full surcharge is then added on top. [3] How the penalty grows, and how a special enrollment period can prevent it, is covered in our article on the Part B late enrollment penalty in North Carolina.
Why a smaller benefit is more exposed
MedPAC says the provision is more likely to affect people with lower Social Security payments, because a cost-of-living percentage produces a smaller dollar raise on a smaller benefit. A person may pay the same premium as the year before, which MedPAC calls fully held harmless. Or the person may pay a variable premium, reduced only enough to keep the net payment from falling. [6]
MedPAC's table is an illustration. The note says the figures use historical information and do not describe actual Part B premiums anticipated in 2027. [6] In the example, a $600 benefit and a $148 premium left a net of $452. A 4 percent cost-of-living adjustment raised the benefit to $624, and a $180 premium would have left $444, so the example cuts the premium to $172 and the net stays $452. [6] A $2,000 benefit rose to $2,080. After the same $180 premium the net was $1,900, still above the prior net of $1,852, so that premium is not reduced. [6]
For a real 2026 comparison, start from the published standard of $202.90 and use the premium you actually paid last year, next to the benefit increase on your own notice. [1][2]
Read the two notices together
Medicare says Social Security will tell you the exact Part B amount for 2026. [2] If the premium is deducted, it comes out of the Social Security or Railroad Retirement payment. If you do not get those benefits, Medicare sends a bill, and the Part B bill generally arrives every three months. [5] Put both papers on the same table: the Social Security notice that shows the new benefit, and the notice or bill that shows the Part B premium for the same year.
A gross benefit can go up while the deposit stays flat. That can be this rule working, not a missing cost-of-living adjustment. A deposit can also rise by less than the announced percentage, because the premium used part of the raise, which is normal when the cost-of-living increase covers the new premium. [1] Keep both notices from the same year. New to Part B, billed directly, a state paying the premium, or an income-related surcharge: those paths do not get the reduced premium. [2][6]
Practical takeaways
- The hold harmless rule can reduce a Part B premium increase so it does not reduce your net Social Security payment. It does not promise the full cost-of-living raise in the deposit. [1]
- It applies only if you were entitled to Social Security for November and December, the December and January Part B premiums were deducted from those benefits, you received a cash benefit for those months, and the premium increase would otherwise make January lower than December. [3]
- For 2026, the standard Part B premium is $202.90, which is $17.90 more than the 2025 standard of $185.00. [1] Social Security tells you the exact amount you will pay. [2]
- You pay that standard amount if you are new to Part B in 2026, you do not get Social Security, you are billed directly, or Medicaid pays your premium. If Medicaid pays it, the state pays the standard $202.90. [2]
- If you pay an income-related monthly adjustment amount, this rule does not apply. [1] That income-related amount affects roughly 8 percent of people with Part B. [4]
- A late enrollment penalty is calculated on the full premium, before any hold harmless reduction, and then added on top. [3]
- Read the Social Security benefit notice and the Part B premium notice or bill for the same year side by side. [2][5]
How we can help
We sit with families in Greensboro and across the Piedmont and read the Social Security notice next to the Part B amount, including the situations this rule does not cover. If a parent is new to Part B, billed directly, or paying an income-related surcharge, we would rather sort that out with the notices in hand than guess from a headline. Have more questions or want to get in touch? Call Seniors Insurance Hub at (336) 937-7501, or send a note through our contact page.
Citations
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Federal Register, "Medicare Program; Medicare Part B Monthly Actuarial Rates, Premium Rates, and Annual Deductible Beginning January 1, 2026" (2025-11-19)
- Medicare, "2026 Medicare costs" (2025-12)
- Social Security Administration, "HI 01001.004 The Variable Supplementary Medical Insurance (VSMI) Premium" (2023-02-02)
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, "2026 Medicare Parts A & B Premiums and Deductibles" (2025-11-14)
- Medicare, "How to Pay Part A & Part B premiums" (2026)
- Medicare Payment Advisory Commission, "Medicare Part B premium" (2026-10)