medicare

Medicare Part D formulary exception: 24 or 72 hours

Medicare Part D formulary exception: 24 or 72 hours

A Medicare drug plan does not have to list every medicine, but you can ask it to cover a Part D drug that is missing from the list, or to charge less for a drug it has placed on a high tier. [1] Those requests are coverage determinations: a formulary exception, and a tiering exception. [2] Your prescriber must support the medical reason, and the plan has a set time to answer. If the answer is no, the next step is an appeal back to the same plan, called a redetermination. [8]

What the drug list is allowed to do

A plan's list of covered drugs is called a formulary. It can include brand-name and generic drugs, plus original biological products and biosimilars. Each list must include at least 2 drugs in the most commonly prescribed categories and classes, and most drugs in these protected classes: cancer drugs, HIV/AIDS drugs, antidepressants, antipsychotics, anticonvulsants, and immunosuppressants for organ transplants. [1]

A specific drug can still be missing. In most cases a similar drug is on the list. If you or your prescriber believe none of the listed drugs will work, you can ask for an exception. [1] Plans also use tiers, and a lower tier generally costs less. Medicare's example, which your plan may not copy, runs from most generics, through preferred and non-preferred brands, up to a specialty tier for very high-cost drugs. If your drug is on a higher tier and your prescriber thinks you need it instead of a similar lower-tier drug, you can ask for a lower copayment or coinsurance. [1]

A plan may change the list during the year under Medicare's guidelines, including when therapies change, new drugs are released, or new medical information comes out. Medicare also says a plan can change the list at any time, and it must notify you if a change affects a drug you take. [1] The exception rules must address a mid-year tier or formulary change when you already use the drug, and the plan must give notice of a negative formulary change. [4] Medicare Open Enrollment runs from October 15 to December 7, changes take effect on January 1, and the plan must have your enrollment request by December 7. [12] Next year's list can differ from the one you have now.

Two different requests

A formulary exception asks the plan to cover a Part D drug that is not on the formulary. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) also uses that name when you ask the plan to set aside a rule on a listed drug, such as step therapy, prior authorization, or a quantity limit. [2]

A tiering exception asks the plan to give you a non-preferred drug at the lower cost sharing that applies to a preferred tier. [2] Both are coverage determinations, the same kind of decision a plan makes when it provides or pays for a drug, sets what you pay, applies a quantity limit or a try-another-drug-first rule, or decides whether you met prior authorization. [3]

If your prescriptions come through a Medicare Advantage plan, the plan still makes this Part D drug decision. A prior authorization for a medical service, or a denial of a hospital stay, is a different process. We describe drug coverage inside those plans on our Medicare Advantage (MAPD) page. This path also cannot obtain a drug that is not a Part D drug. [4]

Who may ask, and what the prescriber must say

You, your prescriber, or your representative may request either exception, and may request a standard or fast coverage determination. [2][3] A request for a drug you have not received yet may be oral or written. A standard request to be paid back for a drug you already bought must be in writing, unless the plan accepts oral payment requests. [3]

You can ask before you reach the pharmacy. Medicare says you contact the plan for an oral or written coverage determination to see whether a drug is covered. [8] For a drug you have not received, send the model form, write a letter, or call. For a drug you already paid for, use a letter or that form. An exception also needs the prescriber's medical reason. [8]

The prescriber may give that support by phone or in writing. If it is oral, the plan may require a written follow-up and more medical records. A written statement can be the model form, the plan's form, or a letter. [2][4]

For a tiering exception, the statement must say that the preferred drug or drugs would not be as effective for you as the requested drug, would have adverse effects, or both. [2][4] For a drug that is not on the list, it must say the drug is medically necessary because all covered Part D drugs on any tier, for the same condition, would not be as effective for you, would have adverse effects, or both. [2][4]

The supporting statement is not an automatic yes. [4] The plan grants a tiering exception when it finds the non-preferred drug medically necessary, consistent with that statement. It must grant a formulary exception when it finds the off-list drug medically necessary, consistent with the prescriber's statement, and the drug would be covered but for being off the formulary. [4]

A plan may block some tiering requests. It may refuse a brand-name drug at a level that applies only to generics or authorized generics, and it may refuse a biological product at a preferred level with no biological alternative. Since January 1, 2022, a plan with one or two specialty tiers may keep those drugs off a tiering exception to a non-specialty tier. [4]

Standard time and fast time

You or your prescriber may ask for a fast coverage determination by phone or in writing. That fast path does not cover payment for a Part D drug you already received. [6] The plan must expedite if it determines, or your prescriber indicates, that the standard wait may seriously jeopardize your life, your health, or your ability to regain maximum function. [6][8]

If the plan refuses to go fast, it still owes you a standard decision. It must tell you that it will use the 72-hour timeframe, that you may file an expedited grievance, and that you may resubmit with your prescriber's support. Written notice of the refusal follows within 3 calendar days. [6]

For an exception, the benefit clock starts when the plan receives the prescriber's statement. Written notice is due within 24 hours on a fast request or 72 hours on a standard request. The first notice may be spoken if a written follow-up is mailed within 3 calendar days, and the plan must answer as quickly as your health requires. [2][5][7] If no statement has arrived by the end of 14 calendar days after the request, the plan must decide no later than 72 hours after those 14 days end, or 24 hours after they end on a fast request. [5][7]

A repayment request, including one that involves an exception, is different. The plan must give written notice, and pay when payment is due, within 14 calendar days after it receives the request. [2][5] If the plan misses a benefit or payment deadline, the miss counts as a denial, and the plan must send the case to the Independent Review Entity within 24 hours after time runs out. [5][7]

If the plan says no

The denial must state the reasons, tell you that you may ask for a redetermination, and, for a drug-coverage denial, describe both the standard and the fast appeal paths. [5] A redetermination is the first appeal, and it goes back to your plan. You, your representative, or your prescriber can ask. Follow the denial notice. [8][9]

Medicare.gov and CMS both say to file within 65 days from the date on the notice. If you are late, give a reason. A fast redetermination may be oral or written. A standard one must be in writing unless the plan accepts a phone request. [8][9] The regulation counts 60 calendar days after receipt and presumes you received the letter 5 calendar days after the date on it, unless evidence shows another day. That presumption is why the consumer pages say 65 days from the printed date. If you can show an earlier receipt, do not wait out 65 days from the printed date. A request for more time must be in writing, must say why you are late, and the plan may allow it for good cause. [10]

Include your name, address, Medicare number, the drug, why you disagree, proof of representation if someone is appointed, and the prescriber statement if you have it. [8] The plan then has 7 days for a standard benefits appeal, 14 days for a payment appeal, and 72 hours for a fast appeal, and it must answer sooner if your health requires it. [8][9] A spoken fast decision is allowed if the written notice is mailed within 3 calendar days. [9] Ask for the fast appeal if waiting the standard 7 days could seriously harm your health. [8]

If the plan upholds the denial, the next step is a reconsideration by the Independent Review Entity. The letter explains how to ask. [9] Medicare.gov gives you 60 days from the date of the redetermination. [8] The regulation gives 60 calendar days after receipt, presumed to be 5 calendar days after the letter date unless evidence shows otherwise. Your prescriber may file after notifying you. For an off-list drug, the prescriber must still determine that all covered Part D drugs on any tier for the same condition would not be as effective, would have adverse effects, or both. [11] Follow each later letter. Do not rely on a dollar minimum printed for an older year.

What a yes covers

An approved tiering exception uses the cost sharing of the preferred alternative. If those alternatives sit on more than one tier, the plan must assign the lowest applicable tier the tiering rules allow. [4]

An approved formulary exception does not let the plan create a special tier, or a special copayment, used only for exception drugs. You also may not add a tiering exception on top of that approved off-list drug. The plan must describe what you will pay. Ask for that amount in the approval notice. [4]

On either approval, the plan may not make you file again for a refill, or for a new prescription after the first refills run out, while your prescriber keeps prescribing the drug, the drug remains safe for your condition, and the enrollment period has not expired. If you renew, the plan may continue the exception into the next plan year, but it does not have to. [4] From October 15 to December 7, ask whether it will carry forward before you stay with the plan. [4][12]

Practical takeaways

  • A drug left off the list is a formulary exception. A drug on a high tier is a tiering exception. The prescriber's statement is different for each. [2][4]
  • You, your prescriber, or your representative can start the request. The prescriber's statement is required, and it is not an automatic yes. [2][4]
  • For a drug you still need, the plan has 72 hours (standard) or 24 hours (fast) after it receives that statement. If the statement is still missing after 14 calendar days, a further 72-hour or 24-hour clock starts then. [2][5][7]
  • Repayment for a drug you already received is a 14-calendar-day decision, and it is not a fast coverage determination. [5][6]
  • A missed deadline counts as a denial. The plan must send the case to the Independent Review Entity within 24 hours after time runs out. [5][7]
  • The first appeal is a redetermination at your plan, filed within 65 days from the date on the denial notice. The plan then has 7 days, 72 hours, or 14 days for a standard benefit, a fast benefit, or a payment. [8]
  • A yes should cover refills for the rest of the enrollment period while the prescriber continues the drug and it stays safe. It may not continue next plan year, so check the new list from October 15 to December 7. [4][12]
  • A specialty-tier drug, a brand compared only with generics, or a biological with no biological alternative on the preferred level may fall outside a tiering exception. Ask before you file. [4]

How we can help

Have more questions or want to get in touch? Our team can sit with you, or with the adult child who is helping, and sort out whether the plan left the drug off the list or only placed it on a high tier. We can help you see what the prescriber needs to say, and whether another plan's list is a cleaner fit before Open Enrollment closes. We are in Greensboro and we work with families across the Piedmont. Call (336) 937-7501 or reach us through our contact page. If the drug benefit is part of a Medicare Advantage plan, start with our Medicare Advantage (MAPD) page.

Citations

  1. Medicare.gov, "How do drug plans work?" (2026)
  2. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, "Exceptions" (2024-09-10)
  3. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, "Coverage Determinations" (2024-09-10)
  4. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, "42 CFR 423.578 Exceptions process" (2026-10-26)
  5. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, "42 CFR 423.568 Standard timeframe and notice requirements for coverage determinations" (2026-10-26)
  6. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, "42 CFR 423.570 Expediting certain coverage determinations" (2026-10-26)
  7. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, "42 CFR 423.572 Timeframes and notice requirements for expedited coverage determinations" (2026-10-26)
  8. Medicare.gov, "Appeals in a Medicare drug plan" (2026)
  9. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, "Redetermination by the Part D Plan Sponsor" (2025-01-07)
  10. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, "42 CFR 423.582 Request for a standard redetermination" (2026-10-26)
  11. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, "42 CFR 423.600 Reconsideration by an independent review entity (IRE)" (2026-10-26)
  12. Medicare.gov, "Open Enrollment" (2026)